A Dime, a Whipping, and the Weight of Empathy
By Jerry McCorkle
Check out Jerry’s short video on this same topic!
Years ago, when my dad was just a boy, he was accused of stealing a dime. But he hadn’t done it.
His brother, Bobby, witnessed my dad being whipped for something he didn’t do.
As my dad told it, something happened in that moment. Bobby felt it deeply—so deeply that he wanted to step in and take the punishment himself. He couldn’t stand seeing his brother suffer for something he didn’t do.

I’ve often wondered what marked my dad more —the pain of the whipping, or the love of a brother who was willing to bear it for him.
That’s empathy.
Not a theory. Not a slogan. But a willingness to step into someone else’s pain—to feel it, and even to carry it.
Today, empathy is sometimes treated with suspicion. You hear arguments that it can be manipulated, that it clouds judgment, that it can even weaken a society. And yes—like anything powerful, it can be misused.
But what happens when we start to see empathy itself as the problem?
Writers like Noah Hawley have observed that when empathy is dismissed, it can give cover to something darker—a desire not to feel at all. If empathy is a flaw, then indifference starts to look like strength.
But Scripture points us in a different direction: “Bear one another’s burdens.”
That’s not weakness. That’s a command rooted in love.
We live in a world where suffering is real—whether close to home or across the globe. And while people will debate causes, policies, and numbers, one thing should remain clear: human lives matter, and our response to suffering matters.
So yes, empathy can be abused. But I’d rather live on the side of history that erred in caring too much than not at all.
Because sometimes the most Christlike thing a person can do is simply say, “Let me take that for you.”